The U.S. Supreme Court sided with Nike in a closely watched trademark dispute involving a covenant not to sue. The Court concluded that such an agreement moots a competitor’s counterclaims of invalidity. However, it was also quick to point out that a party claiming that its voluntary cessation of unlawful conduct renders case moot bears “formidable burden” of showing that it is absolutely clear that alleged unlawful behavior “could not reasonably be expected” to recur.
The dispute began when Nike alleged that two of Already, LLC’s athletic shoes—“Sugars” and “Soulja Boys”—violated Nike’s trademark for its Air Force 1 sneakers. Already denied the allegations and filed a counterclaim challenging the validity of Nike’s trademark. While the suit was pending, Nike issued a “Covenant Not to Sue,” promising not to raise any trademark or unfair competition claims against Already or any affiliated entity based on Already’s existing footwear designs, or any future Already designs that constituted a “colorable imitation” of Already’s current products.
Thereafter, Nike sought to dismiss Already’s invalidity counterclaim based on the argument that the covenant had extinguished the case or controversy. The district court dismissed the claim after finding that “there was no longer a substantial controversy…of sufficient immediacy and reality to warrant the issuance of a declaratory judgment.” The Second Circuit affirmed.
However, the Supreme Court held that a defendant cannot automatically moot a case simply by ending its unlawful conduct once sued. Rather, “a defendant claiming that its voluntary compliance moots a case bears the formidable burden of showing that it is absolutely clear the allegedly wrongful behavior could not reasonably be expected to recur.”
Overall, the decision is good news for trademark registrants because it signals that covenants not to sue can still be used to dismiss an invalidity claim. However, the Supreme Court has arguably raised the bar by articulating a high burden of proof for mooting these actions.
How Can I Help?
If you, or someone you know, need help with any Intellectual Property issue, from filing a patent, trademark or copyright, or just advice regarding how best to protect your ideas and your brand, contact me for a free 30 minute consultation at firstname.lastname@example.org or call TOLL FREE at 1-855-UR IDEAS (1-855-874-3327) and ask for Norman.
– Ex astris, scientia –
I am and avid amateur astronomer and intellectual property attorney in Pasadena, California and I am a Rising Star as rated by Super Lawyers Magazine. As a former Chief Petty Officer in the U.S. Navy, I am a proud member of the Armed Service Committee of the Los Angeles County Bar Association working to aid all active duty and veterans in our communities. Connect with me on Google +